From Hutchins History of Dorset
| Robert MICHEL | pbr. inst. 2 id. May 1327 |
| Mr Stephen de LANGETON | procurator of Robert de Seatington, instituted 4 non. May 1333 |
| John RENNE | deacon, inst. 4 cal. March, 1334 |
| Richard de HULLE | in minoribus ordinibus constitutus, inst. 5 kal. May 1341 |
| Thomas BURCHET | pbr. on the dismission of Hulle, 1 June 1348 |
| Thomas de SKIFFORD | pbr. inst. 21 Aug. 1354 |
| Galfrid IPPELPENNY | pbr. inst. 23 Oct 1394 exchanged with |
| William STUTEVILLE | rector of Puttenham, dioc. Lincoln inst. 14 June, 1395 |
| Richard BELE | clerk, inst. 20 March 1416 |
| Roger HOOTON | chaplain on the death of Beal, inst. 19 Dec. 1455 |
| William GOBARD | chaplain on the death of Howton, inst. 12 April, 1486 |
| Thomas PAYNE | chaplain, inst. 8 Feb. 1520 on the death of ....... |
| John PERYN | cl. pr. to this church of
St Peter the Apostle on the resignation of Payne, inst.
15 Jan 1538 |
| John HAMME | 1545, occurs 1554 |
| Stephen POPINJAY | 1572 |
| James YEROTH | 1579, ob. 1613 |
| Leonard PARRY | 1613, ob. 1623 |
| William BURKETT | 1628 |
| Valentine MING | M.A. Feb. 24 1635 |
| John NEWMAN | 6 Jan. 1665, ob. 1707 |
| Robert HUSSEY | occurs 1708, 1712 |
| Nathanael TEMPLEMAN | Sept. 8 1712, resigned 1716 |
| Isaac CHAPMAN | inst. 24 Sept.1716 |
| Thomas BOND | B.A. inst. March 12 1781, on the death of Chapman |
| John RICHARDS | A.M. St John's Coll. Camb. inst. Sept.
23 1782, on the resignation of Bond. He afterwards assumed the name of Clavell, and died June 14 1834 |
| James Leonard JACKSON | M.A. inst. Nov. 12, 1833, on the death of Clavell |
| Charles ONSLOW | M.A. inst. July 28, 1841, on the resignation of Jackson |
| John Miles COX | M.A. inst. April 4 1850, on the cession of Onslow |
| Owen Luttrell MANSEL | B.A. inst. May 14, 1852, on the resignation of Cox. |
| Herbert Langston WRIGHT | 1898 |
| Cyril Edwin KINDERSLEY | 1922 |
| Henry Lefroy RUSSELL | 1926 |
| Robert Henry FARTHING | 1936 |
| William OUTRAM | 1947 |
| John Lewis JENKINS | 1953 |
| John PRINGLE | 1959 |
| United Benefice of Kimmeridge, Steeple - with - Tyneham and Church Knowle | |
| David Lloyd EVANS | 1966 |
| John HENSON | 1975 |
| United Benefice of Corfe Castle, Kimmeridge, Steeple - with - Tyneham and Church Knowle | |
| Gerald SQUAREY | 1978 |
| Maurice STRIKE | 1991 |